Charly

Also known as: Flowers for Algernon

Genre: medical and behavioural drama 

With: Cliff Robertson (Charly Gordon), Claire Bloom (Alice Kinnian), Lilia Skala (Dr. Anna Strauss), Leon Janney (Dr. Richard Nemur), Ruth White (Mrs. Apple), Dick Van Patten (Bert), Edward McNally (Gimpy), Barney Martin (Hank)

Director: Ralph Nelson

Screenplay: Stirling Silliphant (based on a novel by Daniel Keyes)

Release: 1968

Studio: ABC Pictures, Robertson and Associates, Selmur Productions

Rating: -

MBiS score: 8.2/10

 

Tender Soul Meets Hard Science 

 

QuickView

Story-line: Charly, a child-like man suffering from mental illness, serves as a study subject to Ms. Kinnian and researchers at the Nemur Strauss Clinic in Boston.  

Pluses: a powerhouse, Oscar-winning performance by Cliff Robertson in one of the most wide-ranging roles you can imagine, splendid support from Claire Bloom and cast, tight, tactful and innovative direction that makes efficient use of split screens and chilling dialogues to drive its story, measured production values, an arresting denouement and Ravi Shankar’s sometimes playful, sometimes sad but always apropos musical score.  

Minuses: if you choose to see CHARLY, be mindful that it plays like an emotional rollercoaster with its succession of heartbreaking, hopeful and exhilarating moments.

Comments: this very modest, beautiful and touching story about mental illness, humility and cherished dreams is as rewarding as any in Cinemaland. For a film entrenched in the specific mindset of the 1960s, it packs surprising relevance for today with its comments on the state of the world. Marvel at Cliff Robertson’s performance, alternately playing a child, a mental patient, a rebellious teenager, a mature man and a committed researcher. While Charly struggles to be a better person, he proves how priceless we all are as human beings. 

 

MBiS 

© 2021 – All rights reserved

 Slap Shot

Genre: sports comedy

With: Paul Newman (Reggie Dunlop), Michael Ontkean (Ned Braden), Strother Martin (McGrath), Jennifer Warren (Francine), Lindsay Crouse (Lily), Jerry Houser (Killer Carlson), Andrew Duncan (Jim Carr), Jeff Carlson, Steve Carlson and David Hanson (as Jeff, Steve and Jack Hanson respectively)

Director: George Roy Hill

Screenplay: Nancy Dowd

Release: 1977

Studio: Kings Road Entertainment, Pan Arts Productions, Universal Pictures

Rating: R

MBiS score: 8.0/10

 

Can't Kill Penalties? Try Killing the Ref

 

QuickView

Story-line: as player-coach of the minor-league Charlestown Chiefs, Reggie Dunlop struggles to mould a bunch of prospects, veterans and confirmed losers into a semblance of a hockey team.

Pluses: an unforgettable turn by Paul Newman in a semi-comic role, solid support from Michael Ontkean and a mixed bag of crazies, a frank, truthful and hilarious screenplay by Nancy Dowd, astute direction by George Roy Hill (one roughhouse sequence featuring the Hanson brothers is pure donnybrook) and modest production values in keeping with the subject.

Minuses: there's lots of profanity (mostly in French), indecency, mock violence and general vulgarity but it all comes out as good clean dirty fun.  

Comments: at a time when brawling and disgraceful play were rampant in pro hockey (although it’s still the case today in a number of ways), SLAP SHOT chose to lampoon the senselessness of it all and remains, 44 years after the fact, one of the funniest sports movies ever because of its endearing unpretentiousness. For the sake of your living room, don’t drink beer or eat popcorn while watching this one. 

  

MBiS 

© 2021 – All rights reserved

Anatomy of a Murder

Genre: courtroom drama (in black and white)

With: James Stewart (Paul Biegler), Ben Gazzara (Lt. Frederick Manion), Lee Remick (Laura, Frederick’s wife), Arthur O’Connell (Parnell Emmett McCarthy), Brooks West (Mitch Lodwick, the D.A.), George C. Scott (Claude Dancer), Eve Arden (Maida Rutledge), Murray Hamilton (Alphonse Paquette), Joseph N. Welch (Judge Weaver), Kathryn Grant (Mary Pilant)

Director: Otto Preminger

Screenplay: Wendell Mayes (based on John D. Voelker’s novel)

Release: 1959

Studio: Carlyle Productions (Otto Preminger Films)

Rating: PA

MBiS score: 8.6/10 

 

See You in Court! 

 

QuickView

Story-line: a Michigan lawyer easing his way into retirement is asked to defend an Army officer accused of murder. For Paul Biegler, the veteran barrister, representing Frederick Manion would be quite a challenge since he has never worked for the defence and Manion has clearly caused the death of Barney Quill, a local bar operator.

Pluses: a tremendous turn by James Stewart (notice his voice, his delivery, his looks) and fine support from an awesome cast, a very detailed and wily screenplay filled with suspicious characters, flavourful dialogues and quirky moments, splendid direction and cinematography, credible production values and a swinging musical score by Duke Ellington (who also graces the screen with a cameo).

Minuses: the movie is rather long (2 hours, 40 minutes) but uses every second to develop a complex, intelligent and captivating story. 

Comments: ANATOMY OF A MURDER has a lot to please movie buffs, from admirable performances by older and younger actors to a courtroom duel as intense, messy and disgraceful as you will ever see in cinema. With all its drama, nasty dealings, legal sparring and acrimony, Otto Preminger’s film is everything life shouldn’t be… and everything a great movie should. 

 

MBiS 

© 2021 – All rights reserved

Vérité (la)

English title: The Truth

Genre: judicial drama (in black and white)

With: Brigitte Bardot (Dominique Marceau), Paul Meurisse (Éparvier, the prosecutor), Charles Vanel (Guérin, Dominique’s lawyer), Sami Frey (Gilbert Tellier), Marie-José Nat (Annie, Dominique’s sister), Jean-Loup Reynold (Michel), André Oumansky (Ludovic, from the Spoutnik), Claude Berri (Georges), Jacques Perrin (Jérôme Lamy), Barbara Sommers (Daisy), Louis Seigner (the presiding judge), René Blancard (the general counsel)

Director: Henri-Georges Clouzot

Screenplay: Henri-Georges Clouzot, Simone Drieu, Michèle Perrein, Jérôme Géronimi, Christiane Rochefort and Véra Clouzot

Release: 1960

Studio: Han Productions et al.

Rating: -

MBiS score: 8.3/10

  

One Is Prim, The Other Is Liberated… and I Love ’em Both

  

QuickView

Story-line: when a nun comes over to unlock her prison cell, Dominique Marceau is in no hurry to get out of bed. Her day will be excruciatingly painful. Appearing before judges, barristers and a crowd of strangers, she will be formally tried for the murder of a man she loved.  

Pluses: a remarkable performance by Brigitte Bardot in an unflattering role, strong support from Sami Frey, Paul Meurisse, Charles Vanel and a credible cast, a   straightforward and flawless screenplay that uses flashbacks, dialogues and contradictions to devastating effect and develops tension in a treacherous way, satisfying production values and, of course, efficient direction by a master filmmaker.  

Minuses: none really.

Comments: according to my old Canadian Oxford Dictionary, the word ordeal refers historically to ‟an ancient esp. Germanic test of guilt or innocence by subjection of the accused to severe pain or torture, survival of which was taken as divine proof of innocence”. On a psychological level, Dominique’s treatment by the judicial system in this tragic case may also be considered an ordeal. Barristers trying to top each other in outrage and innuendo, witnesses jousting with the accused, judges intervening, a scavenger press… this kind of process – which faithfully reflects the justice system of the period in France – is much freer and more damaging than what we’re used to in Canada. Not only that, it yields gut-wrenching results in this complicated case of a woman searching cluelessly for a better life. Cynical, implacable but interesting throughout, LA VÉRITÉ stands as another great work by Henri-Georges Clouzot.

 

MBiS 

© 2021 – All rights reserved

Grande illusion (La)

English title: Grand Illusion

Genre: war movie (in black and white)

With: Jean Gabin (Lt. Maréchal), Pierre Fresnay (Capt. de Boeldieu), Erich von Stroheim (Capt. von Rauffenstein), Marcel Dalio (Lt. Rosenthal), Julien Carette (Cartier), Georges Péclet (the Locksmith), Werner Florian (Sgt. Arthur), Jean Dasté (the Teacher), Sylvain Itkine (Lt. Demolder), Gaston Modot (the Engineer), Dita Parlo (Elsa), Jacques Becker (the English officer)  

Director: Jean Renoir

Screenplay: Charles Spaak and Jean Renoir

Release: 1937

Studio: Réalisation d’art cinématographique

Rating: -

MBiS score: 8.9/10 

 

An Old World Blown Away, Never To Return 

 

QuickView

Story-line: France in the early stages of WW I. Maréchal, a working-class officer in the French Army, and Capt. de Boeldieu, an aristocrat, are shot down during a reconnaissance mission. Captured by the Germans, they are taken to Capt. von Rauffenstein, himself an aristocrat, who intends to treat them according to the conventions of war. Thus begins, for our two Frenchmen, a frustrating but eventful new life as POWs in Germany.  

Pluses: a credible cast led by Jean Gabin and Pierre Fresnay – as two very contrasting characters – with fine support from Marcel Dalio, Erich von Stroheim and a brilliant Julien Carette, a tight, thoughtful and detailed screenplay that uses carefully tailored dialogues and soupçons of witty humour to develop its subject, focused direction that maintains a steady pace, irreproachable camera work, modest but well-suited production values, an appropriate musical score and a surprising ending.

Minuses: none I can think of… Jean Renoir’s work is a masterpiece.

Comments: at a time when war was supposed to be a gentlemanly pursuit, World War I – and its unimaginable carnage – shattered old models and brought forth a much darker side of humanity. Such is the focus of LA GRANDE ILLUSION, a classic tale of resilience, uneasy alliances and defiance toward the enemy that doubled as a prescient warning of a second world conflict ahead. No need to comment on the illusion itself… its irony will hit you like a ton of bricks.   

 

MBiS 

© 2021 – All rights reserved

 Fog of War (The)

Also known as: The Fog of War: Eleven Lessons from the Life of Robert S. McNamara

Genre: political documentary

With: Robert McNamara, Errol Morris (the Interviewer); archival footage of Fidel Castro, Barry Goldwater, Lyndon Johnson, John F. Kennedy, Nikita Khrushchev, Richard Nixon and others

Director: Errol Morris

Release: 2003

Studio: Sony Pictures Classics, RadicalMedia, SenArt Films, The Globe Department Store

Rating: PG-13

MBiS score: 8.4/10

 

 

‟Never answer the question asked. Answer the question you wish that had been asked.”

 

QuickView

Story-line: in this chilling documentary, Robert S. McNamara, who acted as Secretary of Defense under Presidents Kennedy and Johnson, talks about his personal and professional life and the lessons he has learned about war and global diplomacy while working with hawks, doves and other species of political birds.  

Pluses: McNamara’s direct and interesting take on our world past and present, strong and studious direction by Errol Morris, a thorough and well-constructed screenplay that uses impactful historical footage, telephone recordings and filler scenes to complement its talking-head format, very astute editing, modest but convenient production values and a superb musical accompaniment by Philip Glass.

Minuses: some viewers may be disturbed by the seriousness of the issues discussed and a couple of odd revelations (skull-breaking experiments?).

Comments: although it follows the usual recipe for documentaries, the Oscar-winning FOG OF WAR never feels static because of its relevance and Robert McNamara’s status as a consummate political insider. Aided by hindsight, he comes out of the exercise as a skilled and forthcoming fellow even when the questions raised are delicate and mistakes need to be acknowledged. At a time when some observers argue that we have entered a new Cold War, his take on the dynamics of diplomacy gives us a clear picture of what our world has become… intimidating, volatile and even scary.

 

MBiS 

© 2021 – All rights reserved

Il buono, il brutto, il cattivo

English title: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

Genre: western movie

With: Eli Wallach (Tuco the Ugly), Clint Eastwood (Blondie the Good), Lee Van Cleef (Angel Eyes the Bad), Aldo Giuffrè (the alcoholic Union Captain), Luigi Pistilli (Father Pablo Ramirez), Rada Rassimov (Maria)

Director: Sergio Leone

Screenplay: Agenore Incrocci, Furio Scarpelli, Luciano Vincenzoni and Sergio Leone (from a story by Luciano Vincenzoni and Sergio Leone)

Release: 1966

Studio: Produzioni Europee Associati, Arturo González Producciones Cinematográficas et al.

Rating: R

MBiS score: 8.7/10 

 

Riding High for Filthy Lucre 

 

QuickView

Story-line: Texas, 1862. While the American Civil War rages on elsewhere in the state, Tuco the meanie survives a showdown with gunslingers in a dusty town. Not far away, another toughie, Angel Eyes, visits Stevens the rancher to inquire about a lost cash box and a missing man named Jackson. As for Blondie, our third protagonist, he shows up when Tuco falls into another trap laid by bounty hunters. As you can plainly see, these guys know how to keep busy!

Pluses: formidable acting from a legendary trio backed by a fine Italian cast, great direction and editing, a distinctive musical score known the world over (by Ennio Morricone), superb camera work and photography (in outdoor scenes especially), an intelligent and unpredictable screenplay built on vivid dialogues, occasional humour and strong suspense, striking settings and sensible production values.

Minuses: as admirable as this movie is, it does contain a couple of unlikely twists (SPOILERS AHEAD!): (1) a dynamite-planting scene is played out far more casually than it should, considering the proximity of enemy fire, and (2) where did Blondie get that horse and rifle in the final scene?

Comments: in the late 1960s, Sergio Leone raised many doubts this side of the Atlantic when he took on a quintessentially American genre – the cowboy movie – but his “spaghetti westerns” were and still are a genuine phenomenon, an astonishing collection of energetic horse operas. This fabulous film has spawned unforgettable roles for Lee Van Cleef (his smirky ways and thin-rimmed hat), Clint Eastwood (with his poncho, cigarillos and fascinating aura) and Eli Wallach (as the short and foul-mouthed pistolero). Though a good notch below ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST, which boasts a richer, wider-ranging screenplay, THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY will bowl you over with its spectacular tale of sometimes heartless and sometimes noble roughnecks.   

 

MBiS 

© 2021 – All rights reserved

 Three Burials

Original title: The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada

Genre: personal adventure drama

With: Tommy Lee Jones (Pete Perkins), Julio Cesar Cedillo (Melquiades Estrada), Melissa Leo (Rachel), Dwight Yoakam (Sheriff Frank Belmont), January Jones (Lou Ann Norton), Barry Pepper (Mike Norton), Vanessa Bauche (Mariana the healer), Levon Helm (the Old Man with the radio)

Director: Tommy Lee Jones

Screenplay: Guillermo Arriaga

Release: 2005

Studio: EuropaCorp, Javelina Film Company

Rating: R

MBiS score: 8.0/10

 

The Title Says Plenty But There’s Quite a Story Behind It  

QuickView

Story-line: when the body of Melquiades Estrada, an illegal immigrant, is found by hunters in the south of Texas, his employer, Pete Perkins, asks for his remains so he can take them back to Mexico. His request is denied but he chooses to press on.  

Pluses: an evenly good cast spearheaded by Tommy Lee Jones, a mysterious, graphic and well-constructed screenplay that uses flashbacks and flashforwards to tell its unusual story in a logical and interesting way, irreproachable direction, fine cinematography (especially in barren areas of the Lone Star State), adequate production values and a genuinely surprising ending.

Minuses: although welcome in such a bleak drama, the screenplay’s humorous moments tend to be macabre. 

Comments: THREE BURIALS is a modest and efficient film that plays on themes of moral duty, remorse, humility and brotherhood. It has no place for heroes – only for common folk who struggle with life, cut corners and sometimes do bad things – and doesn’t try to do more than the essential, a wise choice considering its serious subject matter. Whatever your tastes in cinema, you will find value in this offbeat and sincere contemporary western.   

  

MBiS 

© 2021 – All rights reserved

 Rebelle

English title: War Witch

Genre: humanitarian drama

With: Rachel Mwanza (Komona), Alain Lino Mic Eli Bastien (the Rebel Commander), Serge Kanyinda (the Magician), Mizinga Mwinga (the Grand Tigre Royal), Ralph Prosper (the Butcher), Jean Kabuya (the School camp coach)

Director: Kim Nguyen

Screenplay: Kim Nguyen

Release: 2012

Studio: Item 7, Shen Studio

Rating: 14A

MBiS score: 8.4/10 

 

Sacrificed on the Altar of War    

 

QuickView

Story-line: somewhere in Equatorial Africa, a young woman named Komona speaks to the fetus in her womb: "One day, you will have to come out of my belly and I have to tell you how your mother became a soldier." Haunted by her appalling past, she prays God for the strength to love this child she had never planned on having.

Pluses: flawless acting by Rachel Mwanza and a convincing cast, a frank and logical screenplay that explores a tragic issue seldom discussed in the Western world, excellent direction that meets the technical challenges of location filming, beautiful cinematography (Nicolas Bolduc) and natural settings, professional production values.

Minuses: although some scenes are quite violent, they are essential to show the atrocious fate of child soldiers.

Comments: from the day she is orphaned and abducted at the tender age of 12 to the time of her pregnancy, Komona's life is a succession of horror stories that REBELLE documents unflinchingly but with the sympathy this woman truly deserves. What Québécois director Kim Nguyen has fashioned here is a very different, jarring and impressive film that weaves an extraordinary story and bears witness to human resilience in the face of brutality. This is what I call worthy, valuable cinema. 

 

MBiS 

© 2021 – All rights reserved

 Close Encounters of the Third Kind

Genre: science fiction film

With: Richard Dreyfuss (Roy Neary), François Truffaut (Claude Lacombe), Teri Garr (Ronnie, Roy’s wife), Melinda Dillon (Jillian Guiler), Cary Guffey (Barry, Jillian’s son), Bob Balaban (David Laughlin, the cartographer), J. Patrick McNamara (the project leader)

Director: Steven Spielberg

Screenplay: Steven Spielberg (with help from Hal Barwood, Jerry Belson, John Hill and Matthew Robbins)

Release: 1977

Studio: Julia Phillips and Michael Phillips Productions, EMI Films

Rating: PG

MBiS score: 8.6/10

 

If There Are Intelligent Beings in the Cosmos, Why Would They Bother with Us Humans?

 

QuickView

Story-line: while a French scientist and a group of Americans rush to the Mexican desert to investigate the discovery of training planes lost for decades but still in working order, airline pilots in Indiana report sightings of luminous crafts flying at close range. Also in Indiana, several people witness strange, inexplicable phenomenons.

Pluses: superb acting by Richard Dreyfuss (one of Hollywood’s best in manic, hyperactive roles), François Truffaut (always a treat as an actor) and a disciplined cast, an effective and solidly written screenplay that sustains the mystery throughout and stokes an eerie, unsettling atmosphere, outstanding photography, a celebrated score by John Williams, remarkable special effects and top-grade production values.

Minuses: although the film is international in scope, insistent and annoying product placement gives it a strong (even excessive) American flavour.    

Comments: personally, I was irritated by Steven Spielberg’s constant (and rather manipulative) efforts to whip up a frenzied, hysterical mood around his story – a fault which should have warranted a lower score – but CLOSE ENCOUNTERS OF THE THIRD KIND is truly redeemed by its technical merit and extraordinary ending. By defying conventional wisdom in the sci-fi genre, Spielberg provides a life-altering experience to his characters and otherworldly entertainment for movie buffs. Accept all of it – as little Barry has done – with a child’s openness and trust.   

MBiS 

© 2021 – All rights reserved