Shadows

Genre: social and interracial drama (in black and white)

With: Ben Carruthers (Benny Herd), Lelia Goldoni (Lelia), Hugh Hurd (Hugh), Anthony Ray (Tony Russel), Dennis Sallas (Dennis), Tom Reese (Tom), David Pokitillow (David, Lelia’s friend), Rupert Crosse (Rupert, Hugh’s agent), David Jones (Davey Johnson), Jack Ackerman (Jack)

Director: John Cassavetes

Screenplay: John Cassavetes

Release: 1958

Studio: Lion International

Rating: PG

MBiS score: 8.2/10 

 

‟I am what I am. And nobody tells me what to do.” 

 

QuickView

Story-line: the setting is New York City’s artistic scene in the late 1950s. Benny, a fledgling jazz trumpeter, owes money around town and likes to chase girls with friends Tom and Dennis. Hugh, his older brother, tries to make it as a nightclub singer but his career has hit a wall. As for their young sister Lelia, both Benny and Hugh look after her protectively as she learns about life and love. That’s where Tony comes in… and problems ensue.

Pluses: excellent, natural-looking and wide-ranging performances by Ben Carruthers, Hugh Hurd and particularly Lelia Goldoni, fast-paced, no-frills direction focused on the story itself and human interplay, a serious, loosely structured screenplay that allows its imperfect and somewhat frustrating characters to struggle and evolve through intimate and sometimes kooky situations, informative and atmospheric cinematography, sober production values and a jazzy musical score.

Minuses: because this film is sketchy and improvised, you may find it confusing until you get to know the main characters… but my synopsis will help you figure it out.

Comments: as it follows Benny, Hugh and Lelia through troubles and disappointments, SHADOWS is exactly what it aims to be: an honest, understated slice-of-life drama, a glimpse of people under construction, a series of human experiences in a world of racial differences. This was John Cassavetes’ first try as a director – a promise of things to come – and he let his story meander along unfettered by conventions. As a result, SHADOWS is more authentic than many other films and its truthfulness will please fans of arty, innovative cinema.  

 

MBiS 

© 2025 – All rights reserved