Charly

Also known as: Flowers for Algernon

Genre: medical and behavioural drama 

With: Cliff Robertson (Charly Gordon), Claire Bloom (Alice Kinnian), Lilia Skala (Dr. Anna Strauss), Leon Janney (Dr. Richard Nemur), Ruth White (Mrs. Apple), Dick Van Patten (Bert), Edward McNally (Gimpy), Barney Martin (Hank)

Director: Ralph Nelson

Screenplay: Stirling Silliphant (based on a novel by Daniel Keyes)

Release: 1968

Studio: ABC Pictures, Robertson and Associates, Selmur Productions

Rating: -

MBiS score: 8.2/10

 

Tender Soul Meets Hard Science 

 

QuickView

Story-line: Charly, a child-like man suffering from mental illness, serves as a study subject to Ms. Kinnian and researchers at the Nemur Strauss Clinic in Boston.  

Pluses: a powerhouse, Oscar-winning performance by Cliff Robertson in one of the most wide-ranging roles you can imagine, splendid support from Claire Bloom and cast, tight, tactful and innovative direction that makes efficient use of split screens and chilling dialogues to drive its story, measured production values, an arresting denouement and Ravi Shankar’s sometimes playful, sometimes sad but always apropos musical score.  

Minuses: if you choose to see CHARLY, be mindful that it plays like an emotional rollercoaster with its succession of heartbreaking, hopeful and exhilarating moments.

Comments: this very modest, beautiful and touching story about mental illness, humility and cherished dreams is as rewarding as any in Cinemaland. For a film entrenched in the specific mindset of the 1960s, it packs surprising relevance for today with its comments on the state of the world. Marvel at Cliff Robertson’s performance, alternately playing a child, a mental patient, a rebellious teenager, a mature man and a committed researcher. While Charly struggles to be a better person, he proves how priceless we all are as human beings. 

 

MBiS 

© 2021 – All rights reserved

 Slap Shot

Genre: sports comedy

With: Paul Newman (Reggie Dunlop), Michael Ontkean (Ned Braden), Strother Martin (McGrath), Jennifer Warren (Francine), Lindsay Crouse (Lily), Jerry Houser (Killer Carlson), Andrew Duncan (Jim Carr), Jeff Carlson, Steve Carlson and David Hanson (as Jeff, Steve and Jack Hanson respectively)

Director: George Roy Hill

Screenplay: Nancy Dowd

Release: 1977

Studio: Kings Road Entertainment, Pan Arts Productions, Universal Pictures

Rating: R

MBiS score: 8.0/10

 

Can't Kill Penalties? Try Killing the Ref

 

QuickView

Story-line: as player-coach of the minor-league Charlestown Chiefs, Reggie Dunlop struggles to mould a bunch of prospects, veterans and confirmed losers into a semblance of a hockey team.

Pluses: an unforgettable turn by Paul Newman in a semi-comic role, solid support from Michael Ontkean and a mixed bag of crazies, a frank, truthful and hilarious screenplay by Nancy Dowd, astute direction by George Roy Hill (one roughhouse sequence featuring the Hanson brothers is pure donnybrook) and modest production values in keeping with the subject.

Minuses: there's lots of profanity (mostly in French), indecency, mock violence and general vulgarity but it all comes out as good clean dirty fun.  

Comments: at a time when brawling and disgraceful play were rampant in pro hockey (although it’s still the case today in a number of ways), SLAP SHOT chose to lampoon the senselessness of it all and remains, 44 years after the fact, one of the funniest sports movies ever because of its endearing unpretentiousness. For the sake of your living room, don’t drink beer or eat popcorn while watching this one. 

  

MBiS 

© 2021 – All rights reserved